My intuition tells me that moving duplicatecommon codes among subclasses to the superclass so superclass now have a new method is a bad idea, but i have seen this technique useddescribed in both design pattern and refactoringe. Finding refactorings using lightweight code analysis todd j. Many of these generalizations reflect the less objectcentric nature of the rewrite. It involves moving selected methods and fields between classes. The heart of the book is a catalog of refactorings, organized in chapters on. All of these follow the broad forms of the original book. Ahmedumrysh, developing enterprise java applications with j2ee and uml arlowneustadt, enterprise patterns and mda. With refactoring you can even take a bad design and rework it into a good one. Your subclasses have methods that perform similar work. These are two opposite forms of refactoring involving classes. In some places you may be able to replace use of a subclass with the superclass.
In general pulling up a method looks like a simple copy and paste of code. Most refactoring types improved one or more attributes, except pull up field, pull up method, and rename method. How can i change the default behaviour of eclipse so that it does not prepend the methods it pulls up to an interface with public abstract example, i have a class a that implements interface ia. In the editor, set the caret at the name of a type. This book is closely tied to martin fowlers classic book refactoring f. Refactoring is about improving the design of existing code. How to refactor investigate similar methods in superclasses. Most are minor generalizations, such as changing extract method to extract function. So, first the pull up method and pull up field refactorings. Pull up method is used when there is common method in sub classes and the method is moved. And during your refactoring, you figure out that there is either a duplicate data or duplicate behavior into or more subclasses.
Composite and testdriven refactorings introduction to. This is used when a method needs to be used by multiple implementers. With pull up, you can do pull up field and pull up method refactorings. In some cases a few first edition refactorings are combined. The pull up method refactoring is the process of taking a method and pulling it up in the inheritance chain. Pull up and push down refactoring relates to the ability to move methods and members of a class up into a superclass, or down into a subclass. When you have duplicated code across two separate classes then the best refactoring technique to implement is to pull that duplicate code up into a super class so we dry dont repeat yourself out the code and allow it to be used in multiple places without duplication meaning changes in future only have to happen in one place. Pull up field, pull up method, pull up constructor body. This has important implications for patterndirected refactorings because the mechanics for these refactorings are. The filter panel at the left allows you to select the refactorings by keyword, and also by which books they appear in. One example of abstraction is the pulluppushdown method. This refactoring helps to move type members and implemented interfaces from a derived type up the inheritance hierarchy to a base type. For example, extract method f moves code to a new method, pull up method f moves a method from a subclass to a superclass, extract class f moves code to a new class, and move method f moves a method from one class to another. It contains references to lowlevel refactorings, such as.
The code refactoring techniques in this group streamline methods, remove code duplication. Pull members up select a type in one of the following ways. Improving the design of existing code 99 edition 9780201485677 by martin fowler, kent beck, john brant, william opdyke and don roberts for up to 90% off at. Refactoring to patterns the addisonwesley signature. The pullup method pulls code parts into a superclass in order to eliminate code duplication.
How to refactor create a constructor in a superclass. Systems that have a majority of small methods tend to be easier to extend and maintain because theyre easier to understand and contain less duplication. Finding refactorings using lightweight code analysis. Suppose i added a method void a to a, and i right click on that method, and select refactorpull up, and than make sure void a is selected and i choose the interface ia, and click ok, a method.
Pull up constructor body you have constructors on subclassees with mostly identitcal bodies. Nearly all of the refactorings in this book are composite refactorings. Changes for the 2nd edition of refactoring martin fowler. If methods use a different set of parameters, put the parameters in the form that you want to see in the superclass. The pull up refactoring, however, moves methods and fields from a class to one of its superclasses. Improving the design of existing code shows how refactoring can make objectoriented code simpler and easier to maintain. In particular, extract superclass, inline method, and push down field improved many attributes in conjunction, which confirms recent observations that pull up operations indeed remove poor code structures 1.
As refactoring tools continue to implement lowlevel refactorings, like extract method f, extract class f, and pull up method f, it becomes easier to transform designs by executing sequences of automated refactorings. Place the call for the superclass constructor in the first line in the subclass constructors. With the highly anticipated refactoring to patterns, joshua kerievsky has changed our approach to design by forever uniting patterns with the evolutionary process of refactoring. If you have not followed that recipe, the project is available from the code download bundle under the moverefactor folder in chapter 3. Make sure that the fields are used for the same needs in subclasses.
The extract interface refactoring allows you to create an interface from an existing class. This page also contains the sketch for the refactoring. You move a field from one class to another, pull some code out of a method to make into its own method, and push some code up or down a hierarchy. Although not all of eclipses refactoring features match directly to a refactoring pattern, some are useful to do a part of a refactoring pattern. In most cases, excessively long methods are the root of all evil. Today refactoring requires considerable design knowhow, but once tools become available, all programmers should be able. Pull method is used when there are common fields in sub classes and the field is moved to super class. King department of computer engineering santa clara university 2005 abstract poorly structured code is. It contains references to lowlevel refactorings, such as extract method f extract interface f extract superclass f extract subclass f pull up method f move method f rename method f it also contains references to more sophisticated refactorings, such as. Building better software with archetype patterns and uml arlowneustadt, uml 2 and the unified process, second edition armourmiller, advanced use case modeling. Code refactoring is the process of restructuring existing computer codechanging the factoringwithout changing its external behavior. One would expect that refactoring browser will issue an error message.
Pushdown takes it from a superclass and moves it down into subclasses. Advantages include improved code readability and reduced complexity. Refactoring is intended to improve nonfunctional attributes of the software. Java class salesman extends employee private string name. This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. It is the process of changing a software system in such a way that it does not alter the external behavior of the code, yet improves its internal structure. After some thinking my idea is that now subclasses behavior is coupled to the superclass, and this will make someone who need to maintain. Pull up method you have methods with identical results on subclasses. And with extract interface, you can do the extract interface refactoring. Refactorings selected refactoring level refactoring classlevel inline class collapse hierarchy extract class methodlevel move method extract method pull up method push down method fieldlevel selfencapsulate field encapsulate field move field pull up field push down field table 2. Pull up push down refactoring netbeans ide 8 cookbook. This refactoring is part of the much bigger refactoring course.
Pull up method the pull up method refactoring is the process of taking a method and pulling it up in the inheritance chain. A screencast of one of martin fowlers refactoring patterns from the series called dealing with generalization. We will use the same project from the earlier recipe, rename refactoring, and so ensure that you have the project open from the end of that recipe. The pull up method refactoring identified a duplicated method that reside in multiple subclasses and factors it out in an existing common base class.
Much of refactoring is devoted to correctly composing methods. Refactoring also contains references to more sophisticated refactorings, such as. First we will need a java project so that we can perform some pull up push down refactoring. Code refactoring is one of the key terms in software development and today i would like to talk about code refactoring. Get free shipping on refactoring improving the design of existing code isbn. The vagaries of code inside these methods conceal the execution logic and make the method extremely hard to understand and even harder to change. Extract the common code from the beginning of the constructor of each subclass to the superclass constructor.
Mybaseclass, imyinterface, this refactoring can help you move members of myderivedclass to mybaseclass or imyinterface or to any of their ancestors. This book introduces the theory and practice of patterndirected refactorings. If they arent identical, format them to match each other. Refactoring improving the design of existing code isbn. This book describes the process of refactoring and spends most of its.
698 620 1133 1115 711 804 1209 492 535 832 867 367 751 477 217 1513 931 1480 1459 53 412 320 532 1011 1024 892 817 944 377 532 1246 258 1118 169 996 1344 126 596 539 710 1246 265 953