Adrenaline epinephrine has been an integral component of advanced resuscitation algorithms since the early 1960s. Best evidence topic cardiac general should adrenaline be. T h rainer c e robertson emergency medicine journal 1996. Questioning the use of epinephrine to treat cardiac arrest. Animal and human studies show that in cardiac arrest, adrenaline has positive haemodynamic effects, increasing systemic pressures, myocardial perfusion, and cerebrally directed flow. Recent studies have created substantial concern amongst doctors, nurses, paramedics and patients that adrenaline may be harmful when used as a treatment for cardiac arrest. Use of adrenaline doubles risk of brain damage in cardiac. I had the privilege of speaking at canadas largest em conference, north york generals emergency medicine update conference. An old and established treatment still waiting for supporting evidence adrenaline epinephrine has been used as a treatment for cardiac arrest since the inception of modern day resuscitation.
International resuscitation guidelines recommend administering epinephrine every 3 to 5 min during cardiac arrest resuscitation regardless of the initial rhythm. We believe blinded clinical trial randomization of different dosing frequencies of epinephrine in cardiac arrest would be feasible at the pointofcare. Adrenaline has been part of the standard treatment for cardiac arrest since the early 1960s and may initially help to. Epinephrine and vasopressin use following cardiac arrest.
Although no significant improvement in neurological outcomes has been found among resuscitated patients using epinephrine, including trauma patients, the use of epinephrine is. Adrenaline, cardiac arrest, and evidence based medicine. Adrenaline epinephrine dosing period and survival after. Adrenaline has been used in the treatment of cardiac arrest for many years. The successful use of fibrinolysis in hospital during and after cpr has led to studies of its efficacy during cpr after outofhospital cardiac arrest 73,74. Adrenaline epinephrine in cardiac arrest prehospital.
Scientists publishing in the nejm report that using adrenaline in cardiac arrests results in less than 1% more people leaving hospital alive but nearly doubles the survivors risk of severe brain. The european resuscitation council erc issued the latest edition of guidelines for resuscitation in december 2005. Every 5 years the international liaison committee on resuscitation ilcor assesses the. Guideline for resuscitation in cardiac arrest after. A best evidence topic in cardiac surgery was written according to a structured protocol. Paris, france an association between giving epinephrine during outofhospital cardiac arrest and poor neurological outcomes, with the risk going up with the dosage, was observed in. Routine treatment for cardiac arrest doubles risk of brain damage study this article is more than 1 year old landmark trial likely to change the way cardiac arrest has been treated in the uk.
Full text get a printable copy pdf file of the complete article 231k, or click on a. Principles of management excellent basic life support and its importance excellent cardiopulmonary resuscitation cpr and early defibrillation for appropriately shockable arrhythmias remain the cornerstones of basic and acls 14,15. A clinical trial of the use of adrenaline in cardiac arrests has found that its results in less than 1% more people leaving hospital alive but almost doubles the risk of severe brain damage for survivors of cardiac arrest. In addition to the rebel em post mentioned above emnerd, st. See supportive data for advanced cardiac life support in adults with sudden cardiac arrest. Effect of adrenaline on survival in outofhospital cardiac arrest. Values are higher after an initial asphyxial arrest, with bystander cpr and decline over time after cardiac arrest. A randomized trial of epinephrine in outofhospital. As paramedics, we use adrenalines alpha 1 receptor agonistic properties when we give patients in cardiac arrest adrenaline intravenously, or iv. Noradrenaline concentration and induced a critical vf arrest without cpr 385 mmhg deterioration in. Despite its widespread use, metaanalysis of existing randomised controlled trials has failed to show any effect or benefit on survival to discharge or neurological outcomes. Patients suffering from cardiac arrest could be given a placebo injection instead of adrenaline as part of a clinical trial conducted by researchers at the university of warwick and university of surrey. Even when a medical practice is founded on lessthanperfect scientific data, testing of an established therapy is nearly impossible to justify unless compelling new data lead to questioning of standard care.
This document has stimulated many clinicians managing cardiac surgical patients to evaluate more carefully how cardiac arrests are. Observations inhospital cardiac arrest occurs in over 290 000 adults each year in the united states. In the first of these studies, 40 patients with outofhospital cardiac arrest and with no rosc after 15 minutes of cpr were given 50 mg rtpa over 2. Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following locations. Epinephrine during resuscitation of traumatic cardiac. This is em cases episode 96 beyond acls cardiac arrest live from emu conference 2017 with jordan chenkin. For the first time this included a detailed section on the resuscitation of patients with cardiac arrest after cardiac surgery. Epinephrine is the primary drug administered during cardiopulmonary resuscitation cpr to reverse cardiac arrest. Is epinephrine during cardiac arrest associated with worse. Full text get a printable copy pdf file of the complete article 231k, or click on a page image below to browse page by page. Epinephrine in cardiac arrest in a randomized trial involving 8014 patients with outofhospital cardiac arrest, the use of epinephrine resulted in a significantly higher rate of 30day survival th. I had hoped that there would be some evidence to help identify patients who might benefit from epinephrine, but that is not the case. A comparison of standarddose and highdose epinephrine in cardiac arrest outside the hospital. Animal and human studies show that in cardiac arrest, adrenaline has positive haemodynamic effects, increasing systemic pressures, myocardial perfusion, and cerebrally.
Google scholar brown cg, martin dr, pepe pe, stueven h, cummins ro, gonzalez e, jastremski m. The most exciting scientific progress occurs when new research challenges conventional wisdom. Cardiac life support is a relatively young field of medical expertise with cardiopulmonary resuscitation cpr as we know it only being described in 1960. See the article adrenaline, cardiac arrest, and evidence based medicine. References evidencebased clinical decision support at. The paramedic2 trial is expected to change treatment protocols. Survivors of cardiac arrest have a high incidence of neurological injury. A comment on this article appears in j accid emerg med. Initial guidelines for the treatment of cardiac arrest recommended the use of intracardiac adrenaline 0.
Some individuals may experience chest pain, shortness of breath, or nausea before cardiac arrest. A comment on this article appears in adrenaline, cardiac arrest and evidence based medicine. A recent report from the ontario prehospital advanced life support opals study indicated that 12. Further into the future, if guideline recommendations for epinephrine dose frequency in the treatment of inhospital cardiac arrest become more evidencebased than. Adrenaline versus placebo resuscitation council uk. Patients in cardiac arrest and where there is no doctor immediately available in the coronary care unit. However, the dose, timing and indications for epinephrine use are based on limited animal data. Cardiac arrest is a sudden loss of blood flow resulting from the failure of the heart to pump effectively.
Meeting the challenge this publication was developed by the joint commission with the advice and guidance of a technical advisory panel, and is part of a larger project to identify and address critical factors that will improve prevention and treatment of sudden cardiac arrest both in the hospital and in the community. Pdf adrenaline, cardiac arrest, and evidence based medicine. Adrenaline has never been formally tested as a treatment for cardiac arrest. Beyond acls cardiac arrest care live from emu 2017 em cases.
Mechanical versus manual chest compression for outof. Despite this, inhospital cardiac arrest has received little attention compared with other highrisk cardiovascular conditions, such as stroke, myocardial infarction, and outofhospital cardiac arrest. This 2018 american heart association focused update on advanced cardiovascular life support guidelines summarizes the most recent published evidence for and recommendations on the use of antiarrhythmic drugs during and immediately after shockrefractory ventricular fibrillationpulseless ventricular tachycardia cardiac arrest. Routine treatment for cardiac arrest doubles risk of brain. Even i overestimated the possibility of benefit of epinephrine.
Should adrenaline be routinely used by the resuscitation. Adrenaline, cardiac arrest and evidence based medicine. The prehospital randomised assessment of a mechanical compression device in cardiac arrest paramedic trial was a pragmatic, clusterrandomised openlabel trial including adults with nontraumatic, outofhospital cardiac arrest from four uk ambulance services west midlands, north east england, wales, south central. The alphaadrenergic effects of epinephrine can increase coronary and cerebral perfusion pressure during the resuscitation period 2, 3 and subsequently help achieve return of spontaneous circulation rosc. Doubt cast over adrenaline for cardiac arrest patients. The results are in from the only completed adrenaline epinephrine in noncommonwealth countries vs.
Epinephrine harmshelps in out of hospital cardiac arrest adrenaline in cardiac arrest the resus room. Cardiac arrest trial will test adrenaline against placebo. The question addressed was whether adrenaline might be a useful addition to a protocol for the management of cardiac arrests for patients shortly after cardiac surgery. It increases the likelihood of return of spontaneous circulation rosc, but some studies have shown that it impairs cerebral microcirculatory flow. If not treated within minutes, it typically leads to death the most common cause of cardiac arrest is coronary artery. The problems extrapolating from animal to human data are highlighted. The role of adrenaline in cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Signs include loss of consciousness and abnormal or absent breathing. Contrary to what most people think, were not actually using adrenaline to try and restart the heart during cardiac arrest. It is possible that better shortterm survival comes at the cost of worse longterm outcomes. This is a comment on adrenaline, cardiac arrest, and evidence based medicine.
12 251 611 1356 1540 339 592 1310 1407 451 1285 1 228 410 202 388 1347 598 219 793 197 1239 611 1282 1271 940 658 528 708 303 778 1315 993 471 1055 1307 109 781 1465 1395